Since licensing his show to ESPN and joining College GameDay, Pat McAfee has faced considerable scrutiny—some of which is warranted. However, there’s no denying the value he’s brought to the network, despite ruffling a few feathers along the way. His contributions have led to a revival of GameDay, infusing it with a new energy that has been crucial, especially with the addition of Nick Saban. Together, they helped ESPN achieve its most successful season ever from a ratings perspective.
After just one season, McAfee was uncertain about continuing as a key player on a show that is now integral to college football. However, after some reflection during the offseason, he chose to stay, and that decision has proved to be highly rewarding in multiple ways.
Each week, the former Indianapolis Colts punter’s field-goal kicking contest has become one of the most eagerly awaited segments of the three-hour show. Notably at Cal, McAfee’s challenge resulted in a dramatic $100k kick for Hurricane Helene relief, performed in slip-on Vans. Similarly, Dude Perfect’s Tyler Toney made his own $100k field goal at College Station, and there was also a memorable kick from a soccer player, making the segment as unpredictable as it is essential viewing.
Burke Magnus remarked that “the field-goal kicking contest, which was 100 percent Pat’s idea, has become just as anticipated as Corso’s headgear segment over the years.” Beyond entertainment, McAfee has also put a significant amount of money on the line. According to Phil Mains, the CFO of McAfee’s operations, the field goal-kicking contest has raised an impressive $1.15 million for charity, primarily for Hurricane Helene relief, while awarding $620k to successful kickers.
Through the Field Goal Kicking Contest:
$1,150,000 to charities mostly supporting Hurricane Helene relief + $620,000 to the successful participants https://t.co/RjxY91YEND
— Phil (@philmains) January 17, 2025
Clearly, McAfee’s field goal-kicking contest has transcended mere gimmickry, becoming a significant element of the show.
