Tom Brady didn’t have his best night as a broadcaster calling Super Bowl LIX for Fox, but the seven-time Super Bowl champion quarterback still managed to leave New Orleans a winner thanks to the result of the Big Game. At least that’s how Bill Simmons sees it regarding the Philadelphia Eagles’ 40-22 victory over the Kansas City Chiefs.
Discussing the Super Bowl on the latest episode of The Bill Simmons Podcast, The Ringer founder and guest “Cousin” Sal Iacono noted the unique nature of Brady calling a game featuring the Chiefs amid the emerging “GOAT” debate between the Fox analyst and Patrick Mahomes. “Your boy was giddy too,” Iacono joked. “I think he went like three minutes without talking; Brady was just giggling in the corner. Good for him.”
Simmons chimed in, “Well that’s the thing: If it had been a Mahomes version of 28-3 with Brady announcing, that would’ve been great. Instead, this is probably the best moment of Brady’s career since he retired. Because it was a lot of, ‘Mahomes, Mahomes, Mahomes. Is he the GOAT? I don’t know. Well if he gets his three-peat, Brady’s never done that.’ And now he goes down with two Super Bowl blowout losses. Brady had zero. Brady lost three times in the Super Bowl, all one-score games where he had the ball on the last drive with a chance to steal the game. Never got blown out. And then, he beat Mahomes twice — 2-0 in the playoffs. Can we f**king settle down now for five years with the Mahomes GOAT stuff? Please. Thank you.”
“Can we f—ing settle down now for five years with the Mahomes GOAT stuff?” @BillSimmons and @TheCousinSal react to Patrick Mahomes’s performance in the Super Bowl loss to the Eagles. pic.twitter.com/d9vbrXn50g
— The Ringer (@ringer) February 10, 2025
As a diehard New England Patriots fan, Simmons is obviously biased, but he’s not necessarily wrong. While Brady was always going to have at least three more Super Bowl titles than Mahomes regardless of Sunday’s outcome, the possibility of the Chiefs becoming the first team in NFL history to win three consecutive Super Bowl titles would have added a new wrinkle to a GOAT debate that would have gained momentum. Instead, Mahomes leaves New Orleans with as many Super Bowl titles as he arrived with, firmly securing Brady’s legacy as the greatest quarterback ever. Given that it will take Mahomes at least four more seasons to match Brady’s ring total, the conversation around the GOAT is likely shelved for the foreseeable future.
As for Brady’s current gig? That very much remains a work in progress.
